SurePayroll Reviews

Learn more about SurePayroll - an ideal payroll solution for small businesses. Includes SurePayroll reviews, pricing, and answers to common questions.

Updated on November 26th, 2019

The SMB Guide is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more

SurePayroll Inc. is an online payroll service for small businesses. They offer automated tax filing and flexible payroll options. SurePayroll is owned by Paychex.

Also Consider

Gusto Payroll Software

Get 1 month of Gusto FREE!

Start Free Trial

No extra fees.

Made for mobile.

Auto tax filing and digital paystubs.

Pricing for Small Businesses:

Plan Name

Monthly Pricing

Basic

$29.99 + $4.00 per employee

Standard

$39.99 + $5.00 per employee

Premium

$49.99 + $6.00 per employee

Review:

SurePayroll comes with all standard payroll features as well as a few other services that clients will enjoy. The relatively low monthly fee of $29.99 as well as the variety of services offered makes SurePayroll one of our highest-ranked payroll software solutions.

SurePayroll has a number of less common features like FICA tip credit for restaurants, contractor payments, net-to-gross calculations, easy payroll cancellations, and the ability to collaborate with team members. Some additional features include the option to export data as a spreadsheet or plain text, chat support, banking information management, payroll reminders, 256-bit SSL encryption, and an activity dashboard.

Gusto and Zenefits, our top-ranked payroll software providers, cost a bit more, but offer additional features like minimum wage adjustments on tip credit, accounting and time-tracking integrations, and lifetime accounts, to name a few.

Key Information:

Founder

Troy Henikoff, Michael Alter

Founded

2000

Headquarters

Glenview, IL

Number of Employees

100+

Number of Customers

5,000+

CEO

Martin Mucci

Phone

+1 847-676-8420

Address

2350 Ravine Way, Suite 100, Glenview, IL 60025

Website

www.surepayroll.com

FAQs:

Where is SurePayroll located?

SurePayroll is headquartered at 2350 Ravine Way, Suite 100, Glenview, Illinois.

How do I cancel SurePayroll?

To close your SurePayroll account, contact the customer service team at 1 (877) 956-7873.

How much does SurePayroll cost?

SurePayroll's pricing starts at $29.99 per month plus $4.00 to $6.00 per employee.

What are the benefits of SurePayroll for employees?

SurePayroll for employees is tailored for temporary, seasonal, or independent contractors who don't earn standard salaries. SurePayroll enables accountants to keep payroll data in one place in addition to calculating, filing, and preparing tax documents automatically.

What is the SurePayroll calculator?

The SurePay calculator automatically calculates taxes, wages, and deductions when you enter payroll using an easy three-step process online. Using the calculator ensures accuracy and frees up your time to finish other tasks.

Is Homepay or SurePayroll a better payroll provider for nannies?

HomePay is a special payroll system tailored for nannies and home employees and is priced from $100.00 to $210.00 for a comprehensive service. SurePayroll's nanny payroll service is more economical and easy to use, and most of the admin is done for you.

How does SurePayroll's 401k service work?

SurePayroll's 401(k) service is a separate package that allows you to build retirement savings plans for your employees.

Customer Reviews:

Stephen Kowalski

Reviewed: Jan 11, 2013

Source: CoFoundersLab

I like surepayroll. Handles everything, about half the cost of ADP, good customer support, and can pay from iphone app.

Allan_Branch

Reviewed: Jan 25, 2014

Source: Bootstrapped

We’ve used Surepayroll for a few years, no complaints.

mattstauffer

Reviewed: Jan 03, 2014

Source: Bootstrapped

I just switched to SurePayroll. Their web interface is painfully out of date, and they still do a ton of everything over email/phone… it seems much less fresh and new than the ones you linked. But, so far I’ve been pretty satisfied…

Cloud Phone Nation

Reviewed: Oct 25, 2018

Source: Twitter

I signed up a few months ago. Payroll is now so simple. Keep up the good work!

Phil Cobucci

Reviewed: Nov 06, 2018

Source: Twitter

This is a warning to all of my entrepreneur friends. Stay away from @SurePayroll for your payroll services. Thanks to them I’m paying thousands of dollars to the IRS in unpaid employee taxes. Stay away!